Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Crazy Theory #3: Star Trek Into Darkness and Doctor Who

The 2010s: The decade of Benedict Cumberbatch with his back turned to the camera while he overlooks a city.

I am going to preface this post with the fact that I do not and have not watched that much Star Trek. I did watch Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan at some point last summer, so I know enough to know obviously The Wrath of Khan and Into Darkness are two very different films besides sharing a few plot points that J.J. Abrams tweaked for some silly reason or another. Into Darkness is a straight action film that is kind of about friendship and makeshift families, whereas The Wrath of Khan meditated on aging, friendship, and both biological and makeshift families. I will also note that I saw Star Trek Into Darkness in theaters last summer, months before the release of the 50th anniversary Doctor Who special. So whether or not this gels with that episode, I have not totally determined.

My idea is this: Star Trek Into Darkness is basically an overlong attempt to take the piss out of Doctor Who. This occurs from the first sequence where a father played by Noel Clarke (who also played Mickey Smith, one of the companions/sidekicks of the ninth and tenth Doctors) becomes a reluctant suicide bomber of London's Star Fleet site so his dying daughter will be saved by Harrison/Khan's blood that somehow has superhealing powers. Harrison/Khan is played by Benedict Cumberbatch, an actor that some people want to play Doctor Who at some point although he is rather too busy and famous for that now. Harrison/Khan is living with some form of survivor's guilt, having been brought out of stasis instead of the 900 other people from his planet. It is because of this that he wants revenge, and manipulates Kirk, although leveraging his people somewhat backfires. The people and his planet are known for being war-like, something that perhaps is always on the edge of discussions of Doctor Who and his homeplanet of Gallifrey - until the 50th anniversary special, the Doctor had to end the war between the Timelords and the Daleks by destroying Gallifrey. This is the guilt that Doctors Nine through Eleven lived with, amongst many other guilty feelings. Whether or not the retcon in the 50th anniversary special will somehow backfire remains to be seen.

No comments:

Post a Comment